Президент International Advisers Association, co-founder Firm24
On 1 April, Law No. 4791-IX entered into force, allowing the use of an invoice without the customer's position, full name and signature.
In principle, such transactions could be documented by an invoice before, but the law has reminded us of this option once more by amending the required details of a primary document in Article 9 of the Law on Accounting.
This will not be considered a "violation" if 3 conditions are met:
The legal technique of "is not a violation of the formatting requirements" is new to Ukrainian law-making, and the Main Legal Department of the Verkhovna Rada directly pointed out that the "exception to an exception" construct violates the important principle of legal certainty: "The Law contains a list of mandatory details of a primary document, but does not define a list of violations of the requirements for drawing up a primary document. That is, the draft should have defined certain details of primary documents that are optional for certain types of documents."
The "simplification" still requires some compliance, because it does not apply to: transactions with public funds, lease of state/municipal property, construction contracts, design work, and charitable/humanitarian aid.
The government's "improvement" for business and accountants will most likely not become mass practice, since for one-off transactions involving works and services an oral contract may be used, and it is simpler to sign an act of service delivery than to conclude a full contract. Therefore, the most popular replacement of bilateral acts with a unilateral invoice is expected to be for continuing services (lease) under a written contract.
But the main question is this: if we are joining the EU as soon as possible, and the EU uses exclusively an invoice to record the supply of goods and services, why was the high-quality, comprehensive draft law No. 8125 of 13.10.2022 "On the Use of Invoices in Transactions for the Performance of Works (Provision of Services)", authored by MP Yaroslav Zhelezniak, not adopted right away, instead of dragging out this simple issue?
But for some reason the Ministry of Finance is constantly against invoices.
In EU countries the VAT Directive is implemented, which directly states that 10 details (5 details in simplified ones) in a paper or electronic invoice are sufficient for claiming input VAT, and that is all: no additional tax invoices or acts.
IFRS standards likewise state that what matters for recognising income and expenses is the accountant's professional judgement, not the presence of an invoice, which may be received in a month other than that of the purchase.
09.01.2025
12.05.2020
07.04.2020
29.03.2020