DPO at NOVA group
Imagine that you and a colleague open the same website. You look at the same product but see different prices. The difference is not due to a promotion or a marketer's mistake; the algorithm has simply decided that you are willing to pay more.
Companies in the US and Europe are increasingly using surveillance pricing. This is personalised pricing based on user data. Algorithms analyse purchase history, geolocation, behaviour on the site, device type and other signals. They estimate willingness to pay, or the maximum amount a person is prepared to spend.
At first glance, this is marketing. But regulators are taking a serious and broader view of it. In the US, the FTC is investigating companies (Amazon, Uber). In Europe, personalised prices are being discussed in the context of the GDPR and consumer rights.
The question for business is quite a complex one. Is personalised pricing just marketing, or is it profiling and automated decision-making? If regulators recognise such algorithms as profiling, businesses will face new obligations. They will need to conduct a DPIA and explain to users why exactly they were given a particular price. And such requests will certainly come.
🛠 How surveillance pricing works
Airlines and hotels have long used dynamic pricing, depending on demand or time of purchase. But surveillance pricing changes not the market but the user.
The algorithm analyses dozens of signals to estimate willingness to pay, the maximum amount a particular user is prepared to spend.
I have found myself in such a situation more than once: my wife and I were planning a trip to Rome, looked at tickets for specific dates for several days, and by the time we came to buy, the price had shot up.
Let us be frank: for business, this looks like a logical step in the development of marketing. If an algorithm can determine more precisely the price a customer is willing to pay, the company gets the opportunity to maximise revenue. But for regulators, this practice begins to look different, because the price is determined by analysing the behaviour of a specific person, and then the question arises: "is this profiling within the meaning of the GDPR?" If the answer is yes, it means that the pricing system effectively becomes an automated decision-making algorithm that evaluates the user's personal characteristics. And this is where the legal problem begins.
The GDPR has two articles that are particularly important for personalised pricing:
1. Profiling (Article 4(4) + Article 22) is any automated processing of personal data used to evaluate certain personal aspects of a person, for example financial situation, preferences, behavioural habits, willingness to pay. Surveillance pricing falls within this definition, since the algorithm uses the user's data to determine the maximum price. The problem is that Article 22 of the GDPR restricts automated decision-making that has a significant effect on the user. And here the main question arises. Is a personalised price a significant effect for the user? On the one hand, some say it is just marketing. The price changes automatically, and the algorithm merely adjusts the offer. From this point of view, the effect is insignificant. On the other hand, it can be argued that the price affects access to a product and a person's financial burden. For the user, this already has real consequences, so the effect is significant. Both positions make sense. The only problem is that there is no clear answer yet, and regulators will have to resolve this in the near future.
2. Transparency and information (Articles 12–14), since in Europe the GDPR requires companies to inform users about:
Yet practice shows that most companies simply write: “We use your data for personalised offers” - but do not disclose personalised pricing, which creates a serious compliance risk.
Thus, if a DPA recognises it as profiling, businesses will have to conduct a DPIA, provide an opt-out or another alternative tariff, and also monitor the algorithm for discrimination.
Surveillance pricing demonstrates how closely price personalisation is linked to marketing, AI and privacy. Algorithms that determine how much a user is willing to pay create real legal and compliance risks for business. To be continued....